sábado, 21 de agosto de 2010

Definition of an Avatar - Sai Baba

18 September 2005

Definition of an Avatar

A proper way to analyse the SB phantasmagoria is to present a proper definition of an avatar so that it becomes easier to see if SB fits within such parameters. For now, we'll lay aside the question of whether an avatar is unlimited and is therefore not bound by the strictures of mortals. Recently on the discussion boards a quote from a Kriya Yoga organisation was supplied by an SB adherent in support of their contention that an avatar is susceptible to material miseries and the like. Here is the supplied quote in full:

"The title Avatar describes a fully freed soul incarnating directly from God on this physical planet or elsewhere. An Avatar fulfills a highly spiritual task in the name of God and returns to God after accomplishing his task. His Love for God and his creation is beyond description and imagination, his faith in God absolute as there is no difference between an Avatar and God."

We should also not here that the (generous) definition supplied by the Sai Organisation is as follows:

"An incarnation of God, taking a form according to the age in which the incarnation occurs. Special manifestation of God on Earth."

Elsewhere in Sai literature we note that an avatar is described as "an incarnation of God in human form". It is this very humanity of the avatar that we shall seek to discuss. At the outset, we can observe the obvious conflict(s) in the two definitions provided by the above-mentioned organisations. The former definition appears to be unclear about the ontological status of an avatar and seems to be confused as to whether an avatar is actually God or "someone else"with faith in God. In short, the former definition appears to posit a duality.

The latter definition by the Sai Organisation at least is clear on the matter of the avatar's inherent divinity. The qualifying statement referring to taking a form according to the age is a curious one, and I cautiously assume that whoever made this definition has done his homework and is referring to Bhagavata Purana 10. 8.13, or would that be too much of a high expectation?

But at least we are clear than an avatar is indeed a "special manifestation of God on earth", even if they do say that He comes in a human form.

One of the most disturbing things that Sai Baba has said follows thus:

"The Avatar behaves in a human way so that mankind can feel kinship with Him, but rises to His super-human heights so that mankind can aspire to reach those heights."

By itself it seems reasonable for an avatar to behave in a human way in order to foster friendly relations with mortals, but the dangerous conclusion of believing that the avatar actually is a human and suffering the similar tribulations of a human due to being possessed of a human body is widely prevalent among SB devotees. Not only is it demeaning to suggest such a thing but it is as palpably ridiculous as assuming that a prison governor becomes a prisoner when entering the prison for the purpose of inspection!

The SB adherent who contributed the Kriya Yoga definition (LDW) offered this as the conclusion that she made from that quote:

"Since an avatar is NOT dependent on form, he can take the form of an animal or anything else for that matter, but usually does so as a manifestation of an aspect of the avatar rather than as an 'incarnation,' for short periods of time for the purpose of Divine Intervention."

This makes no sense whatsoever. The appearance of an avatar in the form of an animal or whatever is immaterial since Hindu mythology records such appearances in the form of a fish (Matsya), tortoise (Kurma), and so on. It is widely accepted among devotional scholars that each avatar is a manifestation of God in His fullness, possessing the total range of His powers even if not they are not exhibited or not required to do so. The Dvaita/Tattvavada school of philosophy has made a rigorous analysis of this.

As far as I am aware, the school of Sri Vaishnavism (codified by Ramanujacharya) also believes this. Manifestation of an "aspect" is a status that is reserved for minor empowerments of special souls such as Jesus Christ, Buddha, Prophet Muhummad, Guru Nanak, etc.

LDW further contributed:

"Krishna IS a human who incarnated as the embodiment of Divinity, PERIOD. Krishna IS God in human form as are ALL Masters. Now, do you want to argue with me about that? And don't give me the crap about the form being DIVINE. Any idiot knows that. The point is He is born into a human body. He looks like a human and acts like a human and does experience human travails like any human but his REACTION to them is different."

And considering that this was an interpretation of the Kriya Yoga definition, trying to make sense of this would be beyond human ken. Not only is it so painfully self-contradictory but it betrays a deep-seated ignorance as well.

How exactly is it possible for a human to incarnated as an "embodiment of divinity"? And within the same breath it is declared that Krishna is God in human form? The adherent would do well to make up her mind; is Krishna God or a mortal human? For devotees of Krishna, the answer is abundantly clear.

The premise that since "God comes down to the earthly level He must take a human body" is false and misguided. I can guarantee that anybody who says this would not be able to submit even one scriptural quote in support of this argument. Rather, it is stated everywhere that God (even avatars) have a "body" that is made of pure sac-cid-ananda. It is not a material form at all, it is just pure spiritual substance. Yes, it looks like a human body (providing that the avatar has taken a humanlike form) in which case it would be more correct to say that the avatar is humanlike, not human.

It is quite sad how SB devotees justify every one of SB's illnesses by claiming that he suffers such because he is either taking it on himself on somebody's behalf, or he is just pretending to act like a human in order for mankind to "feel kinship with him". Little do they realise that because Sai Baba is not an avatar, every disease that he suffers is real. Every stone that he treads underfoot hurts. Every hair on his head is vulnerable, and he is just as mortal as the rest of us. He has been blind in one eye for so many years and has undergone several hip operations; all of this cannot be written off as "leela". This is precisely the kind of institutional blasphemy that is inculcated by SB and his org.

To get back to the matter at hand, I find it just typical how SB devotees exhibit their spiritual ignorance by doing what they are most famous for and grabbing at any definition of a subject and following it as if it is inviolable spiritual truth. LDW has done this by ignoring the usual definition of an avatar as given even in SB circles, and has opted to draw her conclusions from the Kriya Yoga definition instead. So that is what we will analyse:

"The title Avatar describes a fully freed soul incarnating directly from God on this physical planet or elsewhere. An Avatar fulfills a highly spiritual task in the name of God and returns to God after accomplishing his task. His Love for God and his creation is beyond description and imagination, his faith in God absolute as there is no difference between an Avatar and God."

I feel that I must wonder where the KY people get the idea than an avatar is a soul, albeit "fully freed"? In this regard I feel that I must present an argument that was originally quoted by Sri Madhvacharya, the founder of the Dvaita/Tattvavada school of Vedanta philosophy. In his rigorous analysis and exegesis, Madhvacharya quoted the Paramopanishad as scriptural evidence for one of his key concepts:

"The difference between the jIva (soul) and Izvara (Creator), and the difference between jaDa (insentient) and Isvara; and the difference between various jIvas, and the difference between jaDa and jIva; and the difference between various jaDas, these five differences make up the universe."

We will note here the first difference; that between the soul and God. The UTTER difference between God and the soul is one of the hallmarks of the Tattvavada philosophy, and such a premise can be supported by a number of scriptural arguments. The Kriya Yoga definition of an avatar thus fails to hold as a logical and coherent explanation of the nature and function of an avatar.

It remains only for SB devotees to think carefully about the spiritual conclusions that they draw from dubious sources, as placing your entire faith on a shaky basis does not bode well for the future. I can only repeat that what I have said in the past, that it is up to the SB devotees to educate themselves and familiarise themselves with the vast body of scriptures available in order to attempt to have some understanding of God, which would also be Sai Baba's advice. As for the proper definition and function of an avatar, the clear answer has been given by Krishna Himself:

Ajo 'pi sann avyayAtma
bhUtAnAm izvaro 'pi san
prakRtiM svAm adhiSThAya
sambhavAmy Atma-mAyayA

"Although I am unborn and My transcendental body never deteriorates, and although I am the Lord of all living entities, I still appear in every millennium in My original transcendental form."

yadA yadA hi dharmasya
glAnir bhavati bhAratha
abhyutthAnam adharmasya
tadAtmAnaM sRjAmy aham

"Whenever and wherever there is a decline in religious practice, O descendant of Bharata, and a predominant rise of irreligion, at that time I descend Myself." - Bhagavad-gita 4. 6-7

Copyright © Sai Baba EXPOSED! 2005-2007. Discuss this post!

Return To Main Page


  • In matters of spiritual existence, it is absolutely essential to pursue the knowledge of the Self ('atmajnyan') and attain to purity of thoughts, words and action. Let every body strive to know his self and attain to divinity by the knowledge of the Self. Bhagavad-Gita implores, "attain to THAt by knowing thy Self (atma), THAT (Supreme Soul/ the Lord Spreme) cannot be known by any other means other than the Self (atma); do not neglect the Soul.-"uddhaaret atmanaatmanam...aatmaanavasadayet".Taitteriya Upanishat reiterates this doctrine. So, let us not bother about what others are and what others do and let us concentrate on our own Self through spiritual exercie of knowing our Self. Never go to another human being for help in spiritual matters since no onw who is an 'attained' soul is ever of any use to us. He is a Muni (Silent).

    It is very important that we should not run behind any body in this pursuit of knowledge of the Self. Since all are traveling in the same boat torn apart in the rough seas of this spaceship earth; no other human being can help us except a divine force! So trust in Lord Krishna who sits as he Antaryamin, the Witnessing Self within our own inner precincts of the heart and guides us if we seek His guidance by keeping our senses withdrawn, mind and intellect quiet, and our individual Prajnya merged in His supreme /Mahat Prajnyaa. Dr. T.N.Achuta Rao.

    By Blogger achuta, at 09 September, 2007 13:38

Post a Comment


Powered by Blogger

Google World Map

Photarium blog directory Blog Directory - photarium

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 2.5 License.

Beast Nature
Baba also constantly encouraged enquiry into tr ...
The 9 Largest Solar-Powered Creations
The 9 Largest Solar-Powered Creations
Be Scofield - Integral Abuse: Andrew Cohen and ...
Tikkun Magazine Pulls Article Critical of Abusi ...
Rajasthan Roots plays its Sufi music at Delhi f ...
MNS legislators to take their oath in Marathi: ...
Firmly Rooted In Islam
Puri Jagannath Temple in Chennai

  1. Sathya Sai Baba - Wikipedia, la enciclopedia libre

    Sathya Sai Baba (23 de noviembre de 1929 o 1926) es un controvertido gurú del sur de la India, con seguidores en todo el mundo. ...
    es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sathya_Sai_Baba - En caché - Similares
  2. Sai Baba - Wikipedia, la enciclopedia libre

    Sai Baba puede referirse a: Sai Baba de Shirdi (1838-1918), un yogui y gurú indio. Sathya Sai Baba, gurú religioso indio, nacido en 1929. ...
    es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sai_Baba - En caché
  3. International Sai Organization

    - [ Traducir esta página ]
    11 Aug 2010 ... This is the web site of the International Sathya Sai Baba Organization, commonly known as the Sai Organization.
    www.sathyasai.org/ - En caché - Similares
  4. Imágenes de Sai Baba

    - Informar sobre las imágenes
  5. Vídeos sobre Sai Baba

    Sri Sathya Sai Baba His work en español ...
    8 min - 18 Abr 2009
    Subido por deSaihaciaSai

    Sundararupaya - Sathya Sai Baba darshan video
    6 min - 28 May 2007
    Subido por nayanparmar

  6. La verdad sobre Sai Baba: Un "dios" se desmorona

    4 Dic 2000 ... Sai Baba se ha hecho famoso por sus curaciones, por la supuesta materialización de una variedad de sustancias que reparte entre su público ...
    www.aciprensa.com/sectas/saibaba.htm - En caché - Similares

    Hace diez años eran muy pocas las personas que habían oído nombrar la lejana villa que lleva el nombre de Puttaparthi, situada en el estado del sureño de la ...
    www.psychics.co.uk/saibaba/saibaba_maestros.html - En caché - Similares
  8. Pagina Principal

    Sai Baba magazine está autorizada por la Organización Sathya Sai Baba de Latinoamerica a ser distribuida en los Centros y Grupos Sai Baba de América Latina. ...
    www.saibabamag.com/ - En caché - Similares
  9. Sathya Sai Baba - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

    - [ Traducir esta página ]
    Sathya Sai Baba born Sathyanarayana Raju on 23 November 1926, is a popular, South Indian guru, spiritual figure and educator. ...
    en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sathya_Sai_Baba - En caché - Similares
  10. Shri Sai Baba - Shirdi Home Page

    - [ Traducir esta página ]
    Life and Teachings of Shirdi Sai Baba, Information on Shirdi, Interactive book to Share Devotees Experiences, Picture Gallery, Automatic Festival Reminder, ...
    www.saibaba.org/ - En caché - Similares
  11. Sai Baba Website

    - [ Traducir esta página ]
    Sai Baba Website. ... How Sathya Sai Baba blessed His Devotee In Her Last Moments ... How Sathya Sai Baba Came as an Old Beggar to Shardamma's House ...
    www.saibaba.ws/ - En caché - Similares

En Andhra Pradesh, en 1926, nació Sai Baba. Desde niño mostró virtudes de compasión, bondad, amor y rectitud, transformándose en el gurú espiritual de su pueblo. Empezó a ser considerado un avatar o reencarnación de Dios cuya misión era nada menos que reunir a las grandes religiones del mundo bajo un mensaje de amor.

Sai Baba

Se dice que Sai Baba tiene poderes más allá de la comprensión humana, incluso científica. La percepción extra sensorial sería uno de ellos, y, al igual que hizo Jesucristo, sus devotos afirman que ha resucitado muertos, multiplicado panes, materializado objetos y que incluso tiene el don de la omnipresencia. Muchas de estas manifestaciones se han producido ante numerosos testigos y se han registrado en documentales. Muchos relatos de testigos y de personas que se han beneficiado de los poderes de Sai Baba con curaciones y otras bondades por circulan en Internet y son materia de debate entre los escépticos que consideran que son simples trucos bien elaborados. Sin embargo, independientemente de si se crea o no en Sai Baba, la mayoría de las personas que están interesadas en fenómenos psíquicos y su estudio han oído ya hablar de Sai Baba.

Sai Baba

Con sus seguidores, ha creado Centros Sai en la India y alrededor del mundo. Lugares de meditación donde las personas desarrollan su propia fe. Algunas de sus funciones son el servicio desinteresado al prójimo, los círculos de estudio, la meditación y la educación en valores humanos. Sus miembros provienen de todas las clases sociales y pertenecen a diversos credos y culturas. Estos Centros Sai han sido con frecuencia el núcleo de la fundación de colegios, escuelas, universidades y hospitales. La India se ha beneficiado enormemente de la labor social que realiza tanto el como sus seguidores, sin costo alguno, desde hospitales hasta obras de agua potable, siendo incluso reconocido por el gobierno.

Realmente, más allá de los actos que realiza o si son estos milagrosos, la importancia de Sai Baba radica en el mensaje que predica. Una frase suya dice “El hombre ha sido puesto sobre la tierra para que descubra la verdad de que el hombre no es hombre sino que en realidad es Dios… cuando el hombre descubra la verdad, entonces podrá reposar tranquilo, con toda propiedad, en paz consigo mismo”. Sugiere además que el amor incondicional es el requisito necesario para que el ser humano evolucione y se transforme en un ser divino.

Tags: , , , ,

Artículos relacionados

10 Comentarios en “Sai Baba y su legado en la India”

  1. 1 Eosaeio feb 16th, 2010 a las 2:42

    Baba es el mas hermoso guia que ha venido a ensenarnos lo valiosos que somos ,para Dios Ñ pero siempre con nuestra forma de ser diabolica lastimamos a los que nos quieren ayudar a salir de esta rueda de ir y venir a este planeta dual ,gobernado por la maldad .

  1. 1 Pushkar, Mumbai y Vanarasi | Absolut India Pingback en nov 26th, 2009 a las 18:22
  2. 2 Turismo de Aventura en India | Absolut India Pingback en nov 26th, 2009 a las 21:41
  3. 3 Hostales en Agra y Vanarasi | Absolut India Pingback en nov 30th, 2009 a las 18:38
  4. 4 Un viaje campestre por Pushkar | Absolut India Pingback en dic 22nd, 2009 a las 18:23
  5. 5 ¿Te animas a ser un voluntario en la India? | Absolut India Pingback en dic 30th, 2009 a las 15:52
  6. 6 Yoga: Una técnica de ejercicios que nació en la India | Absolut India Pingback en ene 25th, 2010 a las 17:37
  7. 7 Autos Honda: Los favoritos de los hindúes | Absolut India Pingback en feb 1st, 2010 a las 4:19
  8. 8 Destinos poco usuales en la India | Absolut India Pingback en mar 12th, 2010 a las 19:34
  9. 9 Enfermedades Respiratorias en la India: Problema de salud nacional | Absolut India Pingback en mar 19th, 2010 a las 19:53

Fuentes - Fonts


bai_____.ttf  - 46 KB
babi____.ttf  - 47 KB
bab_____.ttf  - 45 KB

inbenr11.ttf  - 64 KB
inbeno11.ttf  - 12 KB
inbeni11.ttf  - 12 KB
inbenb11.ttf  - 66 KB
balaram_.ttf  - 45 KB
indevr20.ttf  - 53 KB

free counters

Disculpen las Molestias
Conceptos Hinduistas (1428)SC

Conceptos Hinduistas (2919)SK  ·  (2592)SK
Aa-Ag · Ah-Am · Ana-Anc · And-Anu · Ap-Ar · As-Ax · Ay-Az · Baa-Baq · Bar-Baz · Be-Bhak · Bhal-Bhy · Bo-Bu · Bra · Brh-Bry · Bu-Bz · Caa-Caq · Car-Cay · Ce-Cha · Che-Chi · Cho-Chu · Ci-Cn · Co-Cy · Daa-Dan · Dar-Day · De · Dha-Dny · Do-Dy · Ea-Eo · Ep-Ez · Faa-Fy · Gaa-Gaq · Gar-Gaz · Ge-Gn · Go · Gra-Gy · Haa-Haq · Har-Haz · He-Hindk · Hindu-Histo · Ho-Hy · Ia-Iq · Ir-Is · It-Iy · Jaa-Jaq · Jar-Jay · Je-Jn · Jo-Jy · Kaa-Kaq · Kar-Kaz · Ke-Kh · Ko · Kr · Ku - Kz · Laa-Laq · Lar-Lay · Le-Ln · Lo-Ly · Maa-Mag · Mah · Mai-Maj · Mak-Maq · Mar-Maz · Mb-Mn · Mo-Mz · Naa-Naq · Nar-Naz · Nb-Nn · No-Nz · Oa-Oz · Paa-Paq · Par-Paz · Pe-Ph · Po-Py · Raa-Raq · Rar-Raz · Re-Rn · Ro-Ry · Saa-Sam · San-Sar · Sas-Sg · Sha-Shy · Sia-Sil · Sim-Sn · So - Sq · Sr - St · Su-Sz · Taa-Taq · Tar-Tay · Te-Tn · To-Ty · Ua-Uq · Ur-Us · Vaa-Vaq · Var-Vaz · Ve · Vi-Vn · Vo-Vy · Waa-Wi · Wo-Wy · Yaa-Yav · Ye-Yiy · Yo-Yu · Zaa-Zy


No hay comentarios:

Correo Vaishnava

Mi foto
Correo Devocional

Archivo del blog