miércoles, 23 de diciembre de 2009

Navadwip: The “New Island” hypothesis

Fotos de


24/09/2009
fotos: 33 – 2 MB
Público

Six "relief art" pictures, by artist Sri Raj Kumar Mallick of Krishnanagar, Nadia, West Bengal have been installed in the temple room/"darshan mandap" of the Sri Sri Radha Shyamsundar Mandir at Hare Krishna Land, Baroda. These join three earlier "relief art" picture panels that have been installed in Govinda's Restaurant (which is to open just before Diwali on October 18, 2009). We are planning two more such picture panels to be installed in the temple room, where space for them exists. The size of the picture panels is approximately 10' x 10'.


New "relief art" picture panels installed @ Sri Sri Radha Shyamsundar Mandir, Baroda













Your email updates, powered by FeedBlitz


Here are the latest updates for


"Dandavats" - 6 new articles

  1. Krishna is…
  2. Princes of Belgium loves prasadam
  3. Segments of life: Looking at death under another prospective
  4. Navadwip: The “New Island” hypothesis
  5. ” Preacher”, a poem for the Christmas season
  6. New Book about Srila Prabhupada!
  7. More Recent Articles
  8. Search Dandavats

Krishna is…

By Patita Pavana das

The year was 1933. In Orissa, Professor N.K. Sannyal had just published the first volume of his milestone work on the life of Shri Mahaprabhu under the divine order of his spiritual master, Shrila Bhaktisiddhanta Saraswati.


Princes of Belgium loves prasadam

By Malati dd (LOK)

Thursday 17 dec was the formal inauguration of the Belgian Council of Religious Leaders in the Parliament of Brussels. Hrdaya Caitanya prabhu, temple president of Radhadesh, was elected to represent in the council the Hindus of Belgium.


Segments of life: Looking at death under another prospective

By Matsya Avatara Dasa

Nowadays the great innovations of medical and scientific science can maintain patients alive, even those that in the past were given no hope to survive.


Segments of life: Looking at death under another prospective

Segments of life: Looking at death under another prospective

By Matsya Avatara Dasa

Nowadays the great innovations of medical and scientific science can maintain patients alive, even those that in the past were given no hope to survive. These innovations can prolong the patient’s existence artificially even knowing that they will never regain acceptable health and life conditions. This situation is commonly called over-medication. The definition of cerebral death, since the end of the sixties has allowed for the development of transplant surgery. Before that time, the extraction of organs from a patient with a heartbeat was deemed a felony. Among this scientific and social debate there are ever more crucial questions. Up to which point is it right to keep alive a body that is worn out and unable to grant a minimum of dignity to the psycho-physical entity called person? What is the line that marks the decisive boundary between the unavoidable medical assistance and the over-medication?


The recent story of Eluana Englaro and other similar stories such as those of Piergiorgio Welby and Terry Schiavo, made the whole world think by highlighting the urgency of a serious thinking.
The incomparable value of freedom and of the sacredness and dignity of life and respect to all creatures should be a common patrimony in every social body regardless of its scientific or individual religious orientation. This should be true not only toward human beings but also toward every living being. Life must be protected in each of its manifestation. In the complex human, social and scientific context, it is becoming ever more important and urgent to offer information and teaching on the process of dying and also on the post-mortem phenomena in accordance to medical-scientific prospective but also in accordance to spiritual, humanistic and existential prospective. It should be done by sensibly operating with sincerity so that each person can build, without intrusion or cultural prejudices a clear vision of his will and give and explicit and clear indication through a biological testament and other useful instruments that society indicates and uses for this purpose. We can have better opportunities to self-determine our present and our future if we open ourselves to a deeper comprehension of the death phenomena by taking a distance from various taboos and from the many things removed by the collective imagination that usually hamper a mature elaboration. In fact, only by growing in consciousness we can grow in responsibility and freedom.


For this purpose who is writing has been personally taking care of those so called “incurable” patients and of those medical personnel involved with the taking care and assistance of these patients. He does this by offering instruments of reflection based on the sociological, psychological, philosophical and spiritual Hindu-Vedic tradition. This tradition can significantly extend our perception and conception of the individual and of the death event. We can understand how to extend our perception, through a continuous string of considerations intimately connected among each other and we can also find them in the text: Psychology of the cycle of life – Experience beyond birth and death” (edizioni Centro Studi Bhaktivedante www.c-s-b.org). Let’s not only wonder what to do with the organs of a body that has reached the end of this life. Let’s also think of the future of that person that lived in it and that in accordance with the Hindu-Vedic prospective will continue his existence even after he has left that physical body. How can we help that person still imprisoned in that suit that is now worn-out? How can we stimulate him to prepare himself to abandon it? How can we orient the evolutionary journey that will begin after his clinical death is confirmed?


The answer to these questions is important not only for those that work in the medical field but also for every individual. Welcome, assistance and accompanying are three key concepts in this area.


The meaning of welcoming is meeting the other person, opening not only our arms but also our heart and our mind. The meaning of assisting is intervening with sensitiveness by becoming emphatic and listening to the modalities and the needs of others. The meaning of accompanying is being by the side of a person, without preceding him, but staying almost behind him, being a humble and affectionate person and stimulate him to proceed. Accompanying means staying sensibly alongside and helping him to reach his destination by providing warmth, goodness, empathy, compassion and mercy.


The Hindu-Vedic tradition doesn’t use psychotherapeutic techniques, but offers teachings toward the development of a cosmic vision of life, man and the world that doesn’t concentrate on the resolution of psychological discomfort but on the elevation of a global consciousness. This allows those who apply it to re-discover the entirety of their nature on the bio-physical-spiritual level and express all of their most noble potentialities and aspirations by facing even death in an inner-peace state.


Why does death exist? Who or what dies? How can we prepare ourselves? What does dying consists of? How can we assist a terminally ill person? How can we interact with his family and with medical personnel? By asking ourselves these questions we can reach surprising intuitions, sometimes they make us feel beyond the changing flow of this shining and deceiving world (Veda define it maya which means illusory).


The first question to ask ourselves is: when the objective cure-doctor-medication is no longer reachable, what can we do to take care of the person? Can we transform a traumatic even such as death into an evolutionary experience? The answer is Yes!


The phenomena of death is usually lived as the end of everything, dissolution, disappearance, with tonalities that go from resigned to dramatic all the way to desperate. However, according to the Hindu-Vedic philosophical-spiritual tradition death doesn’t exist as an entity, but only as a concept or a moment of transaction from a segment of life to another. Through a consciousness journey, every human being can learn to “live” it by perceiving that his identity is different from the one of the body and discovering in front of him a new phase of his eternal existence to be projected constructively.


Bhagavad-Gita (II.20) says: “The living being is not born, nor will die. He is eternal. He doesn’t die when the body is destroyed. Tagore writes: we walk when we lift our foot just as much as when we put it down. Like daybreak prepares the new day that will later reaches the sunset, the sunset, through the night, will lead to a new daybreak. Life goes on incessantly and if we understand its evolutionary sense and finally its arcane transcendental meaning, we can overcome even the greatest fear, the fear of death and realize the immortality of our essence, and give a new hope to the deep aspirations of every living being toward authentic freedom and happiness, beyond the limits of space and time.

Readings

Renate Greinert, Cerebral Death and Donation of the Organs, the doubts and inquires of a mother that has donated her son’s organs. Macro Editions 2009.

Navadwip: The “New Island” hypothesis

By Jeevanmukta Das

Earlier I had written an article titled 'Navadwip Notes' in which I discussed the geographical reconstruction of Sridham Navadwip. I now have additional information on the subject and wish to present it here along with the material I had presented earlier


Navadwip: The “New Island” hypothesis

Navadwip: The "New Island" hypothesis

NAVADWIP: THE ‘NEW ISLAND’ HYPOTHESIS

By Jeevanmukta Das

Earlier I had written an article titled ‘Navadwip Notes’ in which I discussed the geographical reconstruction of Sridham Navadwip. I now have additional information on the subject and wish to present it here along with the material I had presented earlier.

As mentioned in my earlier article, I am an amateur landscape archaeologist of sorts, and have recently published a book identifying the real temple of Jerusalem, the one that Solomon built, in the mountains of Modern-day Syria. (Read my book, ‘The Bible Betrayed.’ http://www.thebiblebetrayed.com).

Being a devotee, I decided to apply my so-called expertise in unraveling the mystery concerning Navadwip Dham. One day, while lazily scanning the Dham with Google Earth, I noticed a clear island formation west of the Ganges opposite the current birth-place site. Zooming out a bit I was shocked to find that the whole area was terribly scarred by the virulently oscillating river. Trapped bit of river loops or oxbow lakes were everywhere. I could identify about a dozen or so of such lakes. (Use Google Earth to inspect Navadwip)

Let me explain. At times, when the soil is very sandy or loose, a river tends to undulate into tight loops. Over time, some of these loops break off and gets hemmed in by land when the river short-circuits the loops and eventually migrates away. This action eventually creates the classical formation called ‘oxbow lake’ for it shape is similar to the inverted ‘u’ shaped European yoke used to harness an ox to the plough.

Now, there is a stage that may be said to be one step before the oxbow lake formation. This is when the river has short-circuits the loop but has yet to migrate away. The formation that distinctly stands out at this stage is that of an island trapped within the loop and the river new bed.

The short-circuiting of the loop is a relatively fast development and can literally happen overnight. I mean, you can actually wake one morning to the cries of “dada, the river has broken though; we are now living on an island!” Such being the case, it is quite conceivable that the newly formed island would be dubbed ‘new island’ for want of an immediately available consensus name. In Bengali that would of course be… ‘Navadwip.’ ‘Nava’ means ‘new’ and ‘dwip’ means ‘island.’ Incidentally, ‘oxbow lakes’ and such newly formed ‘river islands’ are seen the world over where ever the river tends to tightly loop.

Now I know very well the ‘nava’ means ‘nine’ and ‘the nine processes of bhakti yoga represented by each of the island’ theology that goes with it. This ideology was first proposed by Narahari and the same was later adopted by Bhakti Vinod Thakur. Unfortunately, a cluster of nine islands, while not improbable, would be difficult to accommodate in this tight region. There is no mention of nine islands in the biographies of Mahaprabhu either. Furthermore, somehow the landscape with its innumerable ‘oxbow lake’ and ‘new island’ formation (see earlier picture) the more accurate rendering of the term ‘Navadwip’ would be ‘new island’ rather than the theologically inspired ‘nine island’ name tag. The ‘new island’ interpretation (although not the formation dynamics that I have elaborated here) is also held by Muslim scholars of nearby Bangladesh.

The first temple built to mark Mahaprabhu’s birthplace was commissioned by Bir Hambir of Vishnupur, who ruled from approximately 1586-1621. This small shrine was claimed by the Ganges. Later, Gaur Govinda Singh, the Diwan of the East India Company under Warren Hastings, built a second temple on the same site in 1780. This sixty foot high building with nine pinnacles in red sandstone too was washed away in floods in 1876.

In 1891, Srila Bhakti Vinod Thakur, after much research, identified a new site as the real birthplace of Mahaprabhu on Anterdwip. This one lies between the Ganges and Jalangi. He called it Sridham Mayapur. Why Mayapur? I do not know, but possibly Mayapur represents the centre of the nine-island theological reconstruction of the Dham. Naturally, the Chaitanya Charitamrita and Chaitanya Bhagavat, do not mention Mayapur and merely offers the name Nadia or Navadwip. Very likely ‘Nadia’ is the truncated version of the original name Navadwip. People tend to drop extraneous syllables to shorten names, make it easier on the tongue and so on and possibly ‘Na-va-di-wi-p’ eventually gave birth to ‘Na-di-a.’

How did Srila Bhakti Vinod Thakur identify Mayapur? Well, the Thakur, it appears, had come across the 1780’s map which Gaur Govinda Singh had produced and or used. Also, he may have used an archaeological ruin mound in the region to triangulate his site. Apart from these mundane pointers, Srila Bhakti Vinod Thakur was guided by a grand vision that indicated this very region.

Unfortunately, I do not have the 1780’s Gaur Govinda Singh map. I do however have a much older map produced by Van der Brouck in 1660. Based on this map, the Ganges flows by the west of Nadia and the river Jalangi apparently forms its eastern border.

Now, I am not quite convinced that the river Jalangi was anywhere close to the core Navadwip area for the simple reason that it is not mentioned anywhere in the biographies of Mahaprabhu. No one is documented to have boated, bathed or got baptized in the Jalangi. Besides, had Jalangi been here, it would eminently have served as the easily identifiable landmark boundary of Nadia and we would have heard statements to the effect that ‘Nadia lies between the River Ganges and Jalangi’ or Nadia was situated at the confluence of the rivers Ganges and Jalangi. What could have been simpler? But no, we do not hear any such thing. Instead, Roop Goswami states in his Stavamala, Vol 4, Navadvipa-Dhamastakam:

sri gauda-dese sura-dirghikayas
tire ‘ti-ramye pura-punya-mayyah
lasantam ananda-bharena nityam
tam sri navadvipam aham smarami

“I mediate on Sri Navadwip that is situated in Sri Gauda Desa by the banks of a heavenly dirghika, and shines with pure eternal bliss.”

Roop Goswami tells us that ‘Navadwip was situated on the banks of a ‘dirghika.’

According to Prof. K. N. Mukerjee, Retired head of the Dept. of Geography, City College, Calcutta, a ‘dirghika’ or ‘dirghi’ (short form) is the generic term for a ‘long water body’ or ‘canal.’ He also states that a ‘dirghi’ played a pivotal role in the identification of Srila Bhakti Vinod Thakur’s Mayapur site.

The fact is, an archaeological ‘Tell’ or mound some 30ft high and spread over 1300 sq ft existed in this region which the locals called by the name ‘Ballal Dhipi.’ Ballal Sen was the king who ruled this region between 1160 and 1178. In 1980, the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI) excavated the Dhipi and found it to contain ruins of an edifice, the nature of which they yet to have determine. (See picture)

Now, to my knowledge, there is no mention of a separate ‘dirghi’ here. Therefore, my guess is the Prof. K. N. Mukerjee got his ‘dirghi’ is by tweaking the term ‘dhipi.’ Archaeologists in general, by the way, are notorious for doing this manner of tweaking and then off they go and anchor some fanciful theory or the other with it! This ‘dhipi tweaked to dirghi’ was conjectured to be the dirghi or dirghika mentioned in the above-mentioned Roop Goswami’s verse, which then would read, ‘Nadia extended from the Ganges to the ‘Ballal Dirghi.’

There is another thing that worries me. As mentioned earlier, the Jalangi is conveniently situated to the east of the currently accepted birth site, and would ideally have served as its eastern boundary. It also happens to be just stone’s throw away from the so-called Ballal Dirghi. So, the question is, why would Roop Goswami have chosen the Ballal dirghi (which is no long there) over Jalangi, a perennial river to mark the boundaries of Nadia? Certainly, Roop Goswami could easily have seen that a more permanent landmark would have been the better choice here than a dirghi however celebrated, for the very practical reason that the dirghi could get obscured in fifty or a hundred years down the road whereas a river is likely to remain almost forever.

Also, the Ballal Dirghi does not offer much in terms of a demarcating boundary. What is needed is a landmark that offers an extended ‘line’ boundary, rather than a ‘point’ on a map. The Ballal Dirghi, even with its purported 1 kilometer length, does not offer a ‘line’ boundary by which to conveniently demarcate Nadia’s eastern boundary. Furthermore, the Ballal Dirghi as depicted in maps, was in fact perpendicular to the Ganges! This further reduces its usefulness as a bounding boundary. In short, the Ballal Dirghi seems contrived and hardly suitable as the eastern boundary of Nadia.

But make no mistake. The Ballal Dirghika was celebrated, had ambrosial, crystal clear water and so on and appears to have been a much appreciated body of water. Even the Muslim scholars parrot these qualities in an unusual show of solidarity. Yet somehow I find it… a bit forced. I mean, I can imagine such a tank being much appreciated in arid Rajasthan… But here, between innumerable tributaries, oxbow lakes and what not, and not to mention the fact that Navadwip goes under eight to ten feet of water like clockwork, who has time for a measly tank however ambrosial its waters?

Yet the fact remains that Roop Goswami does mention a dirghika and not the Jalangi which is merely a few hundred meters away. Given this inexplicable discrepancy one is forced to consider the possibility that Navadwip was perhaps not near the Jalangi and by default, the Ballal dirghi.

Faced with this daunting prospect, we are obliged to reexamine the meaning of the term ‘dirghika.’ What exactly was a ‘dirghika’? Upon reexamining the term ‘dirghika,’ I found that it basically means ‘long,’ as in long ‘e’ instead of short ‘e’ kind of thing and where the difference is often depicted by the use of an arced or curved stroke (or an inverted ‘u’) above alphabet in question. ‘Dirghi’ is also specifically used in various parts of India to denote a long canal. If you combine the two ideologies you could get ‘a long curved canal.’

Remember the oxbow lake formation that I described earlier and how this region was chock-a-bloc with such lakes? Well, an oxbow was most definitely is ‘a long body of water.’ It averaged some 10 odd kilometers in length and eminently qualifies as a ‘Dirghika.’ It is also curved and as such all the more suitable to be indicate by the term ‘Dirghika.’ In short, the term ‘Dirghika’ seems almost the tailor-made Sanskrit equivalent to the English term ‘oxbow lake.’

So the question is, was Roop Goswami Dirghika actually an oxbow lake in the region?

As if in answer to this question, another little bit of the mystery falls neatly into place. I am of course referring to the ‘Navadwip mean a new island formed by an oxbow lake’ ideology I had expounded earlier. If that is so, then we have two classical topographical formations anchoring Navadwip. One is the ‘oxbow lakes’ (Dirghika) and two is the ‘new island’ (Nava dwip) formation. It all irrefutably adds up to the fact that Navadwip was a new island that was formed by an oxbow lake that lay adjacent and west of the River Ganges.

Scanning the map, we see that we do indeed have exactly such a formation. What is more, the oxbow lake in question actually encompasses the Nadia marked in 1660 map! (See map) The map also shows numerous ghats (small ports) along the river. Three or four ghats are mentioned in the biographies of Mahaprabhu so finding it marked on this map is encouraging. I am mentioning this because one could excavate these ghats and use it to triangulate the actual birth-site.

To conclude, Navadwip Dham was exactly where the Thakur say it was. I merely submit that it was perhaps a few hundred yards further to the North-East on roughly the same longitude(see above map). The Ballal Dhipi interpretation that may be said to have created a minor confusion was almost certainly the handiwork of the ‘engineer or archaeologist’ who is known to helped the Thakur process his information.

Staying eternally under the shelter of the loving glances of all the Vaishnavas, I, Jeevanmukta Das, submit these lame arguments for the unlimited pleasure of Srila Bhakti Vinod Thakur.



” Preacher”, a poem for the Christmas season

Madhavendra Puri dasa (Paris): In siddhanta vaishnava, You are Shakti-Avatara: A soul endowed with the power, To take the faith, a step further.


New Book about Srila Prabhupada!

Kaisori (dasi) (BBT): Did you miss the recent festival in London commemorating the 40th anniversary of the Radha-Londonisvara temple? Now you can taste the nectar through a new book just published by the Bhaktivedanta Book Trust


New Book about Srila Prabhupada!

New Book about Srila Prabhupada!

Kaisori (dasi) (BBT): Did you miss the recent festival in London commemorating the 40th anniversary of the Radha-Londonisvara temple? Now you can taste the nectar through a new book just published by the Bhaktivedanta Book Trust:

When the Sun Shines: The Dawn of Hare Krishna in Britain by Ranchor Prime

Available for delivery now!

A historical account of ISKCON’s beginnings and development in Britain, starting with Srila Prabhupada’s early days in San Francisco, his sending of six young disciples to England, and these disciples’ first experiences in London - their first harinamas, their serendipitous meetings with various celebrities in the underground, music, and pop culture scenes, their historic meeting with the Beatles, Prabhupada’s encouragement and finally his arrival to solidify his movement there. The story takes us through the development of ISKCON in London (including the purchase of Bhaktivedanta Manor), Scotland, and Wales, and culminates in a touching account of Srila Prabhupada’s last visit to London in 1977, before he returned to Vrndavana for his final pastimes.

Hard cover, dust jacket
496 pp., 15.1 x 22.8 cm (9 x 6 in) four picture sections - 108 photos in total indexed hand-drawn map on endsheets depicting important sites of Srila Prabhupada’s pastimes in London printed on high-quality archival cream-colored paper individually shrink-wrapped

Ranchor Prime, himself one of the early members of the British Hare Krishna community, has written a sensitive and carefully researched account that weaves together the personal experiences of more than seventy of those who were there, bringing to life this extraordinary story.

Available in Europe and Africa through BLS (http://www.blservices.com)

and in the U. S. and elsewhere through krishna. com and krishnaculture. com.

More Recent Articles



Click here to safely unsubscribe now from "Dandavats" or change your subscription or subscribe


Unsubscribe from all current and future newsletters powered by FeedBlitz
Your requested content delivery powered by FeedBlitz, LLC, 9 Thoreau Way, Sudbury, MA 01776, USA. +1.978.776.9498




Página PRINCIPAL
OBRAS y AUTORES CLÁSICOS
Agradecimientos
Cuadro General

Disculpen las Molestias


No hay comentarios:

Correo Vaishnava

Mi foto
Spain
Correo Devocional

Archivo del blog